Menu
Expat.com

buying apartments

Post new topic

lamyo

Hi . I just bought an apartment in Vitoria ES and the prefecture is asking me to pay more ITBE tax as they have valued my apartment R$200000 more than I paid for it. Does anyone know what I can do to challenge this? Please don't bother to answer if it's a 'well thats how Brazil is' answer!
Thanks in advance.

See also

Real estate listingsAccommodation in BrazilAccommodation in BrasiliaAccommodation in Rio de JaneiroAccommodation in São Paulo
abthree

Hi, lamyo,
We bought an apartment last year (state capital, different state), and this doesn't track our experience at all:  ITBI (I'm assuming that you're talking about the Real Estate Transfer Tax, because I'm not familiar with an "ITBE") was based on our purchase price.   Did you pay a market price for the apartment, or have some kind of special deal?   This is the only case I can think of where the tax might be based on a higher amount.
In your place, my first stop would be at the Cartório that processed/is processing the paperwork (Escritura) for the sale; they should be able to explain the difference.
If they can't, or you're not satisfied with the explanation, the Prefecture's web page on the tax is here:
http://www.vitoria.es.gov.br/cidadao/itbi
Their Taxpayer Services office is here:
Palácio Jerônimo Monteiro
Avenida Marechal Mascarenhas de Moraes, 1.927, Bento Ferreira
I suppose that this would be my next stop.  Good luck!

sprealestatebroker

The assessed tax is , in most cases, based upon the "valor venal", or assessed value by the city upon which said property is under jurisdiction. 

The only other tax which does not strictly follows "valor venal" is the transfer tax or ITBI. On this particular case,  the levied tax is based on whichever value is the highrest, whether it is the Venal or the Negotiated Purchase Price.

In most muncipalities the "valor venal" is way lower than the market value of the property upon consideration.

Trying to challenge the City's declared "Valor Venal " is an exercise of futility, a waste in attorney's fees and your time, unless the "Valor Venal" far exceeds the Market Value.

We had this to take place in Santo Andre, but then, a protesting march was organized and the City receeded in their stance ( call it an organized protest with political consequences to elected officials ).  Whoever then paid the higher tax value will only see a credit towards next year's tax bill.  That City is Santo Andre, SP.

If you are a lone ranger trying to fight off the fairness of Tax Assessor's Office, well, you are in for a big surprise.

abthree

Our experience was in line with sprealestatebroker's description.   Our purchase price was higher than the "valor venal", and the ITBI ended up based on it, although we weren't sure which value the Prefecture would use until they processed the transaction.
We're now waiting for our IPTU documents for this year, and expect to see that the "valor venal" has been adjusted upward to match.

Articles to help you in your expat project in Brazil

  • Accommodation in Salvador de Bahia
    Accommodation in Salvador de Bahia

    Salvador, the capital of the state of Bahia and Brazil's first colonial capital, is a world-known tourist ...

  • Accommodation in Recife
    Accommodation in Recife

    Recife, located on the northeast coast of Brazil, on the tip jutting out into the South Atlantic, is one of ...

  • Using phones in Brazil
    Using phones in Brazil

    It's much easier these days to get a cell phone in Brazil, and phones and calling plans are inexpensive. ...

  • Dating in Brazil
    Dating in Brazil

    If you're single and ready to mingle, then you might want to try your hand at dating after you've settled ...

  • Leisure activities in Brazil
    Leisure activities in Brazil

    Have you always dreamed of dancing to the rhythm of a Brazilian carnival? Do you wish to enjoy the sand and the ...

  • Marriage in Brazil
    Marriage in Brazil

    Brazil can be a romantic country, and you may want to marry here. Perhaps you even want to remain in Brazil ...

  • Childcare in Brazil
    Childcare in Brazil

    As more and more women have joined the workforce in Brazil, childcare has become very important. There are a few ...

  • Driving in Brazil
    Driving in Brazil

    If you‘re moving to Brazil for a short time, then you can use your national driving license. However, if you ...

All of Brazil's guide articles