Menu
Expat.com
Search
Magazine
Search

Brazil is on the brink of a national police strike

James

Sometimes I feel like I have stepped back in time to the days of the "Old West" when the town Sheriff, underpaid and out-gunned, made a heroic effort to protect the local population from bandits.

Brazil is more like the "Old West" than it was in the USA's past history and there is no sign of it getting better anytime soon. The PEC 300, a proposed national salary base for police and firefighters has been stalled in Congress since early in 2010. Governors of many Brazilian states are doing everything in their power to see to it that it does not come up for a congressional vote this year. Police throughout the country who receive sub-standard salaries threaten a nationwide strike which would throw Brazil into absolute chaos. (see linked R7 report at http://noticias.r7.com/brasil/noticias/ … 11107.html )

It is a shameful situation and ironic in that the richest states pay their police and firefighters the lowest salaries. For example, Rio de Janeiro the second largest economy in Brazil in terms of GDP, pays its Civil Police R$1530 per month, the lowest salary for Civil Police in all of Brazil. It pays Military Police a pathetic R$1137 per month only marginally better than the lowest paid in Brazil (RS at R$996). It makes no sense whatsoever that in Sergipe, the smallest state in the union and 21st in terms of GDP, police officers earn salaries almost double those in Rio de Janeiro. In Brasilia, DF Civil Police earn the highest in Brazil at R$7514 while Military Police get R$4129. São Paulo the country's largest economy isn't much better either - here police earn just over R$2200 a month.

In order to survive with sub-standard salaries police all over the country are forced to take secondary employment, which in most cases is better paid than their policing positions. This means that they generally devote more time and attention to the secondary job than to being police officers and we all suffer in terms of a total lack of public security for this reason.

Federal politicians couldn't really care less, since they are well policed in Brasilia. State politicians are busting their butts to maintain the status quo and keep wages shamefully low. Rio de Janeiro is just the worst example... and they try and feed us all the crap that they are capable of hosting such world class events as the World Cup 2014 and the Olympic Games. FALA SÉRIO, GENTE!!!

See also

Living in Brazil: the expat guideNew members of the Brazil forum, introduce yourselves here - 2025Resident cardOrdinary Naturalization and Getting PassportBrazilian Employment // Occupancy LawIRPF - Late submission fineManaging meals in Brazil
dell1

What about the Brazil Federal Police ? I understand they are paid about 10 times more than the state ones . Is this accurate ?

James

Hi Dell1,

I don't have any figures on the pay scale of Federal Police, but it wouldn't surprise me if you are correct. There is an alarming diparity in they salaries of people doing relatively the same work in every sector here.

Regards,
James

James

I first posted this article back in October of last year, since then things have continued to get worse. Both Salvador, BA and Rio de Janeiro are in the midst of police strikes and other cities are set to follow just in time for Carnaval.

Looks like the most popular Carnaval costume won't be a costume at all, but a soldier's uniform... Rio will be receiving no less than 14 thousand soldiers. God knows how many more in Salvador.

Is a nationwide base salary for police officers really too much to ask for? Why is it that the richest states pay their police officers and firefighters a pitance while their politicians keep raising their already absurdly high salaries?

James

The following list show the salary for the Military Police (Soldado 1° Class) for each of the states and the Federal District from the highest paid to the lowest. The figure on the right is the state’s ranking in terms of GDP (2009). It clearly shows that the police officer’s salary has little if anything to the state’s ability to pay; the richest states pay the lowest salaries in most cases. The median salary is around R$1.500,00 (just over 2 X the minimum wage).

Salary PM Soldado 1° Class State by GDP(2009)
01- Distrito Federal – R$4.129.73 - 07
02- Sergipe – R$3.012.00 - 22
03- Goiás – R$2.722.00 - 09
04- São Paulo – R$2.387.00 - 01
05- Mato Grosso do Sul – R$2.176.00 - 17   
06- Amapá – R$2.070.00 - 25
07- Maranhão – R$2.037.39 - 16
08- Alagoas – R$1.818.56 - 20
09- Espírito Santo – R$1.801.14    - 11
10- Paraná – R$1.789.00    - 05
11- Mato Grosso – R$1.796.71 - 14
12- Minas Gerais – R$1.775.42 - 03
13- Santa Catarina – R$1.600.00    - 08
14- Tocantins – R$1.572.00 - 24
15- Bahia – R$1.550.00 - 06
16- Amazonas – R$1.546.00 - 15
17- Roraima – R$1.526.91 - 27
18- Piauí – R$1.372.00 - 23
19- Acre – R$1.299.81 - 26
20- Paraíba – R$1.297.88 - 18
21- Rondônia – R$1.251.00 - 21
22- Pernambuco – R$1.237.29 - 10
23- Pará – R$1.200.00 - 13
24- Ceará – R$1.147.00 - 12
25- Rio de Janeiro – R$1.137.49    - 02
26- Rio Grande do Norte – R$1.111.00 - 19
27- Rio Grande do Sul – R$996.00 - 04



Minister of Justice José Eduardo Cardozo says that the PEC 300, which is designed to equalize police salaries, is unviable. How so? When a Federal Deputy makes the following:

•     Monthly Salary: R$ 16.512,09;
•    13º,+ 14º e 15º Salaries;
•    Housing Allowance; R$ 3.000,00;
•    Telephone Allowance: R$ 4.000,00;
•    Transportation Allowance; R$ 9.000,00;
•    Magazine/Newspaper Subscriptions; R$ 1.000,00;
•    Medical Coverage: R$ 8.000,00;
•    Other Indemnification: R$ 15.000,00

This is a staggering total of R$56.512,09 per month, not counting the 13th, 14th and 15th salaries and the other funds for operating his/her political offices (almost 91 X minimum wage).

State Deputies receive about 75% of that which a Federal Deputy gets. They also vote themselves a nice pay raise whenever the mood strikes them and you never hear the Minister of Justice or any of them saying that it is UNVIABLE.

It is shameful that in a country as wealthy as Brazil the Minimum Wage is so low that it violates the Constitution and even police officers and firefighters don’t get a decent living salary.