banking in Ecuador

jillnsy New member

6POSTS

14 years ago

I have just joined your forum in hopes to get some real answers from real people who feel the same way we do. We are retiring to Ecuador in June 2012 most likely on the ocean (Crucita)or a little south of Manta.We live in Ontario Canada right now. We are in the process of selling off all our goods and home,cars,boats and timeshares. If anyone can help us with banking - especially pensions automatically dep. into Canadian accounts and how to get monies to Ecuador. Recommend a bank in Ecuador that we could deal with. We also have visa and residency questions. If anyone is available to talk this through with us - please contact us.

1 member reacted to this post

See also

Opening a bank account in Ecuador - Guide
Bank loans in Ecuador - 34 Replies
Bank Fees Ecuador - 10 Replies
Evolution of banking services in Ecuador - 5 Replies
Where and why do you have a bank account in Ecuador? - 4 Replies
Cuenca Banking - 62 Replies
Changes to banking with limited access to US Dollar supplies - 10 Replies

Harmonie ViP

19273POSTS

14 years ago

Hello jillnsy and welcome to Expat.com!

Do not hesitate to browse through the forum, it may help.

Harmonie.

Mehrlyn Active member

49POSTS

14 years ago

Good day. There are a number of people on this site who will probaubly add to what I am going to write, and some will disagree with what I am writting but as a fellow resident of Ontario (Toronto) I just had to offer my assistance which I hope is of value to you.
Most of the expats on this site are from the Unitied States and have opened accounts in Miami, Fla. I do not know exactly why but I guess it is because Miami is one of the hubs that people fly out of to get here. I still have my accounts in Canada and I can access them via the ATM's that most of the banks have here in Quito. Service charges are the issue as the Canadian banks charge $5.00 per transaction. (at least that is what mine charges.) Using the ATM's is the best way to get money here. If you have your pensions deposited in the Canadian bank then you have no need to transfer money to a bank here.
The only reason to open an account here would be for safe keeping of your cash, or to use the bank as a method of paying bills. I opened an account at the same bank that my employer is using (I am an expat but I am working here untill October.) in hopes that it would make the process of cashing or depositing my cheque easier. It only slightly helps. I still need to show my passport to cash the cheque and access to my money in the account is available through ATM's but with a very small daily limit. Sending money back home is VERY expensive. 5% of the amount being transfered (if it is over $1000.00, or $55 if less than $1000.00) so if you want to use Canadian credit cards add 5% to your bill every time you want to pay it. I do not know if you can get a CC in Ecuador as an Expat.
I do not know the tax implications of having money deposited in Canada and then being brought into this country. You may get dinged with double the taxes? As it stand with me my Canadian income stays in Canada and my Ecuadorian income gets used here. Taxes are paid to both countries but only on the income earned in that country.
BTW, NONE of the Canadian banks have any form of a relationship with banks in this country, and from what I have seen none of the American banks do either. I hope this is a start in your search for information and I hope other expats will be of greater service to you. BTW, look me up when you get down here in June as it would be great to meet a fellow Canadian Expat.
Kind regards,
John

jillnsy New member

6POSTS

14 years ago

So great to hear from you John. You are right - 99 % of what you read is aimed for US citizens. Glad to find a fellow Canuck to share ideas and suggestions. I have contacted ING and their service charges and 2.00 per international transaction. I have also heard the Charles Schwab.com offers ZERO FEES for international transactions. Calling tonight to talk with them. Will let you know the result. Csn'y wait to get there and start the new adventure. Hope to talk soon. Oh by the way, we are from Orillia.Are you there on a work visa? I have read that you need to have an ecudorian acct. to apply for pensioners visa? No anything about this? Have a great day John and. thanks
Jill

Mehrlyn Active member

49POSTS

14 years ago

Good day Jill.

Yes I am here on a work visa. The company I work for in Canada is working with a Brazilian company to build the new airport in Quito. I was transfered down here in September and I love living and working here. The country is beautiful and from a job site point of view it is a big change to look at mountains instead of other buildings while you work.
Not sure about the requirements for a pension visa or entry requirements as my company took care of all that. Best advice I can give is to have some other expat recommend a good immagration lawyer and do it that way. Canadian or the US expat, it should not much matter as I suspect it would be the same requirements for any expat.
I know Orillia well, I helped build the condo's at Panoramic Point over look lake Couchaching. My grand father was also raised in Orillia and Leacock's character of "Dean Drone" was loosely based on my great grandfather.
Look forward to talking to you and maybe meeting in June. Good luck with all your preparations.
John

Dispirit Active member

30POSTS

14 years ago

Hello my name is Diane and I will be coming over to EC in July.

I have read much on ATM's in Ecuador for getting cash. I was wondering if the banks in Ecuador will cash traveler's checks, or maybe you need an account with an Ecuadorian bank before they would cash them. If anyone has the answer to this question, I would appreciate their experiences.

PETRA_AND_UWE Member

11POSTS

14 years ago

We are also from ontario, Canada and I write a BLOG about our experiences in Ecuador. We just opened an Ecuadorian bank account with Banco Pichincha- they allow you to open an account with a Censo( identity card if staying more than 3 months) .
Please read the Jan.26 entry at the following site

http://uwepetrastravelyear.blogspot.com … count.html

I really think you should try Ecuador first before finally moving here. We have had some friends who became disilusioned after the 4 month honeymoon pereod and moved back home. Please remember that this is a third world country and magazines like International Living paint a very rosy picture.

1 member reacted to this post

Dispirit Active member

30POSTS

14 years ago

This forum seems to apply to Canadians. If someone from the U.S. has had any experience with cashing travelers checks at an Ecuadorian bank, please let me know. I see from answers in this forum that the banks would not accept a Canadian bank check, I wonder if that is the same policy for American bank checks?
Thank you for any information in this regard,
Diane

Mehrlyn Active member

49POSTS

14 years ago

I copied this from the web site "Ecuador-travel.info"

" Changing Money & Checks
As a result of dollarization, we recommend more than ever that you carry both US bills and traveler's checks while in Ecuador. Other foreign currencies can be difficult and in most cases are impossible to change outside of Quito, Cuenca, and Guayaquil. In Quito, the stretch of Avenida Amazonas (Gringo Ave.) between La Patria and Colón and also, more to the north, between República and Río Coca will cover most of your financial needs. There is quite a range of banks, ATMs, "casas de cambio" (money changing houses), and money transfer facilities. In Guayaquil you will find a similar area dedicated to financial services on the first few blocks of Avenida 9 de Octubre near the Malecón 2000 boarwalk and café area which is on the waterfront.

Traveler's Checks
Traveler's checks are a great way to keep track of your funds while away from home. Best of all, if they end up lost or stolen they are relatively easy to replace, though some companies reimburse you faster than others. American Express usually replaces checks within 24 hours, while lesser-known companies can take well over a week.
You should be aware that checks can sometimes be difficult to change outside of big cities. In small towns, unless highly touristed, traveler's checks will be met with blank looks. So it's a real good idea to get them cashed before you go on a side trip ouside of the big city."

It appears that since Ecuador uses the Ameribuck it is not an issue to use travel cheques. I did not see anything about "personal cheques" which may be a different issue as would cheques drawn on a foreign bank, ie company cheques. I just googled "cashing travellers cheques" and this was the first site to come up. Hope this Canadian was able to help.

3lckr Serial expat

204POSTS

14 years ago

#10

Everything said here is correct, I'm just going to share my experience with banks here. Open a savings account in Banco Pichincha and look no further, a number of branches and the efficiency of its employees surpass any other bank. They give you a visa check card with $600 per day withdrawal limit. They also have a direct SWIFT code (w/o intermediate banks), so if you wire yourself money from abroad, it will appear on your account quickly.
It is true that if you send money out of Ecuador, anything over $1000 is a subject to 5% tax in addition to money transfer fees. I also opened an account in Banco Pichincha Miami (there is a branch in Quito in 6 de Diciembre and Portugal) and it is a very convenient way to move your money between here and there (or there and here), still $1000 limit applies if you don't want to pay 5%.
Ecuador has a very efficient banking system, to my surprise, much more efficient than Panama, for example.
Good luck to all.

jillnsy New member

6POSTS

14 years ago

#11

So from reading thru this forum on banking, it sounds like it can be as simple or confusing as you make it. We are meeting with RBC today to see what type of package they offer. Apparently this vip plan works well for Cnds. The cost is 30.00/month but you get 2 cnd. accounts, one amer. account and a choice of credit cards (u.s. gold visa is one of them). International transactions are free. Banking in Ecuador looks like it can be done on-line using our Cnd. accounts. It will just take some money shuffling. Don't know if an account in Ecuador is needed? Probably just to pay household bills? and to accept a wire transfer when we purchase a home? Either way, we are still going thru with the plans to relocate/retire and continue to sell of all our assets/possessions. We embrace a new culture and a affordable retirement which is much deserved that we can't get here. If it absolutely won't work for us in Ecuador, we'll move on to the next amazing country. We are out to live our life and exprience Ecuador with all it has to offer. It is still the visa requirements and residency that have us a little confused. Can anyone tell me step by step how to go thru this process? Have a great day all!
Mango7 - we will look into this bank when we get there - it may work too.

PETRA_AND_UWE Member

11POSTS

14 years ago

#12

We got our 6 month visa at the Ecuador Consulate in Toronto- see link
http://www.embassyecuador.ca/english/in … ular&nro=2
There is also lots of info at that site. Check to make sure you have all required paperwork with you eg criminal check, birth certificate etc. There is a full list in the Embassy web site.

You can also apply while you are in Ecuador using any number of qualified lawyers. Our recommended person is Sebastian Cordova in Quito who can be reached at scordero@gcabogados.com

Good luck and hope to keep in touch.

Dispirit Active member

30POSTS

14 years ago

#13

Thank you Merlyn: the info you provided with regard to travelers cheques was very helpful. There is so much research to be done before embarking on this journey. So everyone who shares their experiences makes it easier. Thanks to all.

mojo1953 Member

12POSTS

13 years ago

#14

Looking for banking information also! If you had any luck finding out which banks have the least fees and How best to transfer funds from US to Equador banks please respond. Friend moving to Equador in april, I will do the same next year.

Luna2 Active member

81POSTS

13 years ago

#15

Mojo,

You can use your atm and credit card in Ecuador to get cash out. Also you can open a bank account once you get your cedula. Wells Fargo is the cheapest way we have found to transfer money.
DO NOT bring travelers checks, they are hard if not impossible to cash!! Read about Ecuador at http://www.atruetalltale.wordpress.com
Will give you a great perspective of life on the ground.

ibokay Member

10POSTS

13 years ago

#16

Travelers Checks are easily cashed at VAZ bank (not the travel agency) at Gran Columbia and Luis Cordero in Cuenca. I also agree that Wells Fargo is the cheapest and easiest way to transfer money to Ecuador. Depending upon your total balance (checking, savings, cd's, etc.)transfer fees are as low as $2 per transaction. After initial set up, it only takes a few moments using your computer to transfer funds. Last time I checked, the limits were $1000/day or $9000/month max. Can either be to cash (picked up without further fees) or to your account at Bank of Guayaquil. BTW - I've heard that Wells has hooked up with some other banks here as well. Check their website.

mojo1953 Member

12POSTS

13 years ago

#17

Thanks for the advise.

Nemesis5 Guest

0POSTS

13 years ago

#18

As a Gringo, you can open a bank account in banco the Pinchincha without a shedula. The whole process is easy. Ask to a local friend for their >latest< utilities bill (cable TV, etc), it is one of the documents they will ask you.

Av. Amazonas 4545 y Pereira, Edf. Centro Financiero - Norte - Quito. Talk to Sebastian, he speaks English.

Banco de Guayaquil should avoided, unless you want to discover just how bad things can get here.

Superintendencia de Bancos y Seguros (SBS), if you have a complain/problems about banks in Ecuador, but they really are just a front for the banks and don't do much.

ibokay Member

10POSTS

13 years ago

#19

Sounds like Rawdon may have had a bad experience with Banco de Guayaquil at some point. My initial experience with opening an account there, was more comical than anything else. Because their website definitely indicated that extranjeros did not require a cedula we went armed with copies every other possible document known to man. After entering all our data into their system, we were told, "Sorry", but a cedula is required. Several months later with my brand new cedula in hand, I returned to re-apply. This time I was told that someone with exactly my same name already had an account and unless I could get a certain document from the municipality, I would be denied an account. Some days later with the new document in hand, returned and submitted same. A few moments later, a very embarrassed young lady informed me that they had in fact opened an account for me using the original application that we had submitted some 5 months earlier. We had had an account with zero activity and zero balance all along! What could a person do but laugh out loud....... Anyhow, it's been smooth sailing ever since. Statements are on time and accurate, window service is good, some online banking is available, my Internet is paid directly, and last but not least - my cash transfers from Wells Fargo Bank in the USA are completed online in a matter of minutes. While there may be other banks in Ecuador that give as good or better service, I'm perfectly happy with BdG. Oh - almost forgot - they have opened what are known as Banco del Barrios - a series of "mini banks" located throughout the city in places like tiendas and such where one can pickup a couple hundred in cash, make deposits, etc. - exactly like the supermarket based branches back home.

danceprof Member

3POSTS

12 years ago

#20

Hallo, I am dance teacher and choreographer from Europe and I want to move to Ecuador with my family in october. First i want to come with friend in july for 1 month to see how is the life there, and to find a house on the coast for my family. How I can transfer the money from my country in Ecuador,when is impossible for stranger to open a bank account in Ecuador? Greetings

timo31750 Contributor

127POSTS

12 years ago

#21

Hello Canadians, your comments on Charles Schwab's fees is correct, I have been with Schwab for over 10 years and I would never never again use any bank. I don't care what or who they are or say.
Schwab is courteous, professional and most transactions including ATM fees are credited back tour checking account. They also pay interest on your checking balances. I believe they allow 1 fund transfer per quarter free? Verify that. But the question is why bother when all you need is your ATM card for cash.
You can make arrangements with them to raise your limits to whatever level you feel you need to operate.
Great folks.

russelleaton Active member

79POSTS

12 years ago

#22

Forget travellers checks in Ecuador, nobody will cash them or accept them unless you go ot a major bank in a major city. Also, forget $50 or $100 dollar notes - they are not accepted anywhere and cannot be changed anywhere except in the main central bank of Ecuador or a main bank like Banco Pichincha. Even $20 dollar notes are difficult to change when you're out and about. ATM's are no problem. My advice to anyone coming to Ecuador or living/staying in Ecuador is to bring, say, $500 and just use ATM's to get cash from your account at home. Or open an bank account in Panama, and take money from that account using ATM's in Ecuador.
If you're not Ecuadorian, you can still open a bank account in Ecuador for local living, but keep as little as possible in the account, say up to $10,000. For example the Banco Internacional will give you a current account with a checkbook, but you will need to present a passport and some kind of bill that proves where you live.
If you ever send money out of Ecuador you get clobbered with a $50-$100 handling fee, plus a tax of 5% of the amount sent abroad if the amount is over $1000.
Beware that you cannot assume your bank records are kept confidential in Ecuador. Bank employees are known to sometimes snoop on private accounts. It has been known for a bank empoyee to tell friends about an account holding a lot money and the name and address of the account holder, thus putting that person at risk. So my advice is to keep savings below $10,000 which should not draw particular attention. If you have to make a large payment (e.g. buying a house or a car) it's much better to make a bank transfer from you account abroad direct to the company selling the house or car, instead of making the payment via your Ecuadorian bank account.
Hope all this helps,
Russell Eaton
www.deliveredonline.com

BobH Serial expat

841POSTS

12 years ago

#23

russelleaton wrote:
... forget $50 or $100 dollar notes - they are not accepted anywhere and cannot be changed anywhere except in the main central bank of Ecuador or a main bank like Banco Pichincha. Even $20 dollar notes are difficult to change when you're out and about.

I agree in part. $100s are worthless.

As for the rest, it depends on where you're shopping. I recommend using common sense in offering 'large' bills for payment.

I've used fifties in larger stores on a few occasions. It makes perfect sense to give a fifty when paying for say $35 of groceries in a supermercado, and I haven't had a negative reaction from the checkout clerks.

Twenties are no problem at all, though I sure wouldn't offer one to a street vendor when I buy two bucks of strawberries. The ATMs give most of their money in twenties -- when I get $200, the ATM dispenses it as nine twenties and two tens.

russelleaton Active member

79POSTS

12 years ago

#24

You never come across $50 or $100 dollar notes when living in Ecuador. But yes, if you give a $50 note to a checkout clerk in a large reputable store such as Supermaxi, they will eye it suscpiciously, hold it up to the light, and if it looks okay, it will be accepted. When out and about it is generally best to have 5 and 10 notes.
Incidentally, ATM's are good and plentiful and there's no problem getting up to $500 from a foreign account or up to $200 daily from an Ecuadorian account.
Russell Eaton
deliveredonline.com

mugtech ViP

4732POSTS

12 years ago

#25

timo31750 wrote:
Hello Canadians, your comments on Charles Schwab's fees is correct, I have been with Schwab for over 10 years and I would never never again use any bank. I don't care what or who they are or say.
Schwab is courteous, professional and most transactions including ATM fees are credited back tour checking account. They also pay interest on your checking balances. I believe they allow 1 fund transfer per quarter free? Verify that. But the question is why bother when all you need is your ATM card for cash.
You can make arrangements with them to raise your limits to whatever level you feel you need to operate.
Great folks.

Charles Schwab founded Bethlehem Steel, deserves our deepest respect.

becominganexpat Member

1POSTS

11 years ago

#26

I love Charles Schwab! I am charged zero fees, zero currency transaction fees, and am reimbursed the ATM fees from other banks! I wanted to know if Charles Schwab offers this account to Canadians, and if so what is the link? I believe it's called high yield investor checking account (if my memory serves me right).

laurenceoliver New member

8POSTS

11 years ago

#27

Jill,ifyou need info on visa/s.
try calling Ecuadorean Consulate in Toronto...416-413-9569.
they speak English.....and will answer your questions...Good luck...

mugtech ViP

4732POSTS

11 years ago

#28

laurenceoliver wrote:
Jill,ifyou need info on visa/s.
try calling Ecuadorean Consulate in Toronto...416-413-9569.
they speak English.....and will answer your questions...Good luck...

Jill last posted on the forum in April of 2012.
So I would not be "banking" on getting a reply.

rach3vb Member

1POSTS

11 years ago

#29

Does anyone know about the ability to send money from Ecuador to the US and who has the lowest fees? Is it really only transactions under $1000 that don't get the 5% and how many are you limited to? I want to send much more than a thousand... my concern is that making money there won't make much sense if I can't get it back to the US. There are no fees for bringing cash up to $10,000 home when I fly, correct? I guess I could just go back and forth a bunch!

Please let me know any advise you might have. Thanks!

mugtech ViP

4732POSTS

11 years ago

#30

Bringing slightly less than $10,000 cash into the USA several times will put you on the radar screen. Being USA citizens you will need to report your world wide income, and the IRS just loves people who do all of their business in cash.

1 member reacted to this post

cccmedia Ecuador/Colombia Expert

10285POSTS

11 years ago

#31

rach3vb wrote:
Does anyone know about the ability to send money from Ecuador to the US and who has the lowest fees?....I want to send much more than a thousand... my concern is that making money there won't make much sense if I can't get it back to the US....Please let me know any advise you might have.

If you want to wire "dinero" from Ecuador, you will probably need a bank account in EC from which to send it. Most banks here require that you have the national ID card or "cedula" in order to open an account. If you know and trust someone in Ecuador, theoretically you might could send it from their account.

Also...Ecuador: not the best place in the world to be carrying large amounts of cash. I personally would consider it a major security risk to my person and would not do it.

cccmedia in Quito

Nemesis5 Guest

0POSTS

11 years ago

#32

Dumb question...Did EC sign on to FATCA? ....If so, then money in an EC bank would be reported to IRS.

mugtech ViP

4732POSTS

11 years ago

#33

suefrankdahl wrote:
Dumb question...Did EC sign on to FATCA? ....If so, then money in an EC bank would be reported to IRS.

No, but several banks did on their own. You can get the latest list on the IRS Website.

netbean Active member

78POSTS

11 years ago

#34

I have a CD from the bank, "placed in custody of Banco Central del Ecuador" how to get the file from the central bank, where is the office in GYE?

cccmedia Ecuador/Colombia Expert

10285POSTS

11 years ago

#35

netbean wrote:
I have a CD from the bank, "placed in custody of Banco Central del Ecuador" how to get the file from the central bank, where is the office in GYE?

As some readers may know, a bank Certificate of Deposit ($25,000 minimum at last report) is a favored route toward an EC investment visa.

If you're seeking a residency visa and this kind of early issue is already stymying you, Net, consider getting a pro to help with the visa process.

Immigration attorneys and (less expensive) visa specialists are available.

Some posters on Expat.com have reported doing the visa deal on their own and they promote such a concept, but many of us who got assistance are glad we did.

Paperwork can become a bear, and the angst can eat you up. When the you-know-what hits you-know-where, it's a great feeling to have someone who has navigated these waters on your side. (Pardon my use of metaphors.)

Also to mention, the procedures and the way they are interpreted are subject to change. One way this plays out is EC official(s) asking solo petitioners to come back repeatedly with new paperwork...or even with previously submitted documents that seemingly slipped away.

When the U.S. State Department blew a call and delayed one of my apostilles past the EC visa-application deadline, my experienced attorney here in Quito knew just what to do and how to do it. We sailed successfully ahead and got the visa earlier this year.

If this post doesn't exactly fit your needs, Net (I don't know where that office is in GYE), perhaps it can assist some other reader.

cccmedia in Quito

LLGM Active member

52POSTS

11 years ago

#36

Hi, I'm new to Expatblog,

The topic at this forum seems to be focused on banking in Ecuador and I'm trying to reach US Expats who may be having trouble with banking, likely mostly due to FATCA.

If any of you are really concerned about FATCA, and want to know about a serious, now in the courts legal action against FATCA plus one country's IGA, take a look at the #2 posting over at

FATCA and FBAR in Brazil; who's running the show here anyway??? on the Brazil forum. It's maybe the only chance in the world for US Expats (and anyone else disturbed by this unmitigated extortion) to try to fight this invasive, extraterritorial law.

Happy New Year from Canada
LLGM

SawMan Serial expat

577POSTS

11 years ago

#37

LLGM wrote:
It's maybe the only chance in the world for US Expats (and anyone else disturbed by this unmitigated extortion) to try to fight this invasive, extraterritorial law.

This lawsuit, even if successful (which it won't be) will have no effect whatsoever, especially on U.S expats living outside Canada and going back to a pre-FATCA world is not going to happen, so says Canadian lawyers familiar with the suit.

http://www.moodysgartner.com/is-the-can … w-Original

LLGM Active member

52POSTS

11 years ago

#38

SawMan wrote:
LLGM wrote:
It's maybe the only chance in the world for US Expats (and anyone else disturbed by this unmitigated extortion) to try to fight this invasive, extraterritorial law.

This lawsuit, even if successful (which it won't be) will have no effect whatsoever, especially on U.S expats living outside Canada and going back to a pre-FATCA world is not going to happen, so says Canadian lawyers familiar with the suit.

http://www.moodysgartner.com/is-the-can … w-Original

Interesting article. And what do you know about Jim Bopp and the Republican Overseas law suit? If the Supreme Court rules that FATCA is unconstitutional in the US, and the IGAs that were signed round the world are not legal treaties, and the Republicans have on their position papers that they will move to kill FATCA, don't you think that a win in Canada might shake the foundation just a wee bit?

Perhaps in 1776 Roy Berg et al would have sided with the British, deemed a Tory (in Canada he would have been called a "Loyalist"). Basically, it is a similar issue; it is sad that the US doesn't recognize that irony.

(Side issue: Already countries are looking for an alternative to the US being the head-honcho for international financial transactions. FATCA is going to hurt the US in the long-run)

SawMan Serial expat

577POSTS

11 years ago

#39

LLGM wrote:
SawMan wrote:
LLGM wrote:
It's maybe the only chance in the world for US Expats (and anyone else disturbed by this unmitigated extortion) to try to fight this invasive, extraterritorial law.

This lawsuit, even if successful (which it won't be) will have no effect whatsoever, especially on U.S expats living outside Canada and going back to a pre-FATCA world is not going to happen, so says Canadian lawyers familiar with the suit.

http://www.moodysgartner.com/is-the-can … w-Original

Interesting article. And what do you know about Jim Bopp and the Republican Overseas law suit? If the Supreme Court rules that FATCA is unconstitutional in the US, and the IGAs that were signed round the world are not legal treaties, and the Republicans have on their position papers that they will move to kill FATCA, don't you think that a win in Canada might shake the foundation just a wee bit?

No. The Canadian lawsuit plaintiffs claim that FATCA as it is being implemented in Canada violates the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Canadian court will not rule on U.S. law. If the plaintiffs want to contend that FATCA violates U.S. law (including U.S. Constitution) then a suit would have to be brought in the U.S.

LLGM Active member

52POSTS

11 years ago

#40

SawMan - The Canadian lawsuit makes no claims about US law, only the infringement of Canadian law in Canada.
Jim Bopp and Republicans Overseas will have to do their legal work inside the US to overthrow FATCA.

But I still contend that the Canadian case will be closely watched by other countries and may encourage them to reconsider their decisions RE FATCA. After all, many of these countries now have signed - - or are about to sign - - on to GATCA (which, it is doubtful the US will join as it is based on residency-based-taxation, with no provision for citizen based taxation since that is what 99% of the world's countries use; the US needs to come into the 21st century!!!).

If the US moved to residency-based taxation, they would restrain themselves to look at only US-residing "tax-cheats" who are hiding money overseas, rather than spending time and manpower criminalizing all US citizens who choose to live outside the homeland. Besides, most of the wealthy US-citizen money-hiders/tax cheats live IN THE US....