Surabaya to become alcohol free city

My only point Fred, is let’s try to be accurate when we make comments about Bali. 

Bali is not a place where seeing folks drinking until passing out is “very common.”

I hope you understand why I do not appreciate that false picture of Bali…especially when it’s coming from the board’s designated expert.   ;)   Someone reading this thread just might take your comment seriously...and that would be a shame.

OK, OK, OK, the bad bits in the south of Bali.
I'm assured the non drunken fools areas are the majority of the island and they're lovely.

Now we can hug again.   :o

Cheers, and good night!

Ubudian :

Now we can hug again.

Dude, unless you're around 18 to 30 years old, a very pretty lady and promise not to tell my wife, you have zero chance of a hug.
You would have but I stopped drinking ... and wearing skirts, but that's a story for another day.

The possible alcohol ban is very unlikely, but a lot of that depends on who is making cash from the sales.
You've already mentioned the cash raked in by one hotel, and that's a likely picture all over Indonesia, so someone will lose out in a large way if it gets banned.
Do they have any political influence, or will they just have to live with a ban?

tel522 :

As I understood it the government of RI wanted to increase tourism all over indonesia, re the proposed alcohol ban in surabaya , a few days ago  some members of parliament wished the proposed ban to be extended all over indonesia including local production , ya these things come up every ramadan , but if it gets through forget about tourism , also its a dis-incentive for investment here .

we shall see !
30 may
News  from Jakarta Post page 2....

If passed, law will impose full nationwide ban on production, distribution, consumption of drinks with 1%-55% alcohol content House expects to pass bill by July 28.

“The title will be deliberated later to speed up the process,” said leader of a House special committee for the alcohol prohibition bill, Mohammad Arwani Thomafi, a lawmaker from the United Development Party (PPP) which, together with fellow Islamoriented party the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS), has sponsored the bill.

As you summarised.
There has been strange going on indeed in Indonesian Parliament. It seems the executive and the legislative government are not in direct sync on many instances.
Legislative went on producing many laws that could be construe as not running common sense. And the executive would later on playing catch ups.

The general feel of the majority of the populace, I believe would separate alcohol in 2 types:

1) Alcohol content less than 10 percent - usually beer to be freely distributed, with the exception rule to minors.

2) Alcohol content more than 10 percent considered "Miras - Minuman Keras" should be regulated and permit to sell should be monitored more closely.

If the blanket ban of 1 percent above alcohol content were to be in effect - it could be too damaging beyond belief.
The same as earlier last year when the issue of closing time of nightlife venues went on for a long debate. In the end, the issue died down and things went back to normal. It was a knee jerk reactions and many concealed insiders were trying to score points and curry favors traded.

It seems to happen every year. Covert corruption perhaps. We put pressure on you (government)  from the top of the pyramid (Muslim Brotherhood)  and accept some under the table deals instead of the regulations being passed. (Is that too far fetched to be possible ?)

I recall years ago when I first moved to Bali that night spots in Jakarta were fairly regularly raided and often trashed by extremist groups, especially during the fasting month.  As an outside observer looking in, it seems to me that if anything, this “preoccupation” with alcohol has become more limited in recent years.  For those who have been in Jakarta for say the past 18 or so years, is that a fair analysis?

Yes. They have escilated from the street level to where the real money is Politicians dens. Booze was so cheap. And life was fun in Jakarta around 1999. But things have changed . Globullization has come sweeping accross the nation. Everywhere has lost its vibe. Its all pose with a bottle and take selfies. So glad I stopped drinking so I no longer have to put up with fake people and drunken expats.

Getting rid of booze from Alfa and sevel was easy because not many people cared either way, but taking it out of a whole country is more of an issue as it takes in tourism and that means cash, so perhaps it all depends on who is making how much from selling booze.
At the end of the day, you always have to see who will gain what from political moves, but that isn't always cash.

No pun intended, but the final law/regulation regarding alcohol as just passed is a much watered down version of what was originally proposed and passed by the Surabaya city council back in March.  As revised, hotels and night clubs will continue to be able to sell liquor…and that’s no surprise.  Back in March it was a split 6 to 4 vote in favor of a total ban…no exceptions.   

Fred, you asked, just a few posts earlier…

“You've already mentioned the cash raked in by one hotel, and that's a likely picture all over Indonesia, so someone will lose out in a large way if it gets banned.  Do they have any political influence, or will they just have to live with a ban?”

It would be an easier list to compile showing prominent Indonesian political families that do not own hotels here in Indonesia than a list of those who do. 

For purely practical and economic reasons, there will never be total bans on alcohol across Indonesia.

Even for Indonesian in Surabaya, it is very hard to get some drinks to buy :D bars and pubs are the only place where drinks can be enjoyable :)

Surabaya has never really been a draw for tourists, except for transit. The City of Heroes has been a magnet for local business people with both legal and illegal diversions.
As a transit point for trips to Bali, Bromo, East, Central and West Java Surabaya was a great spot to enjoy the nightlife or just grab a couple of cold beer and head back to the hotel or Kost (depending on budget)
Grabbing a cold beer is more time consuming now and the lack of it will encourage people to stay in their rooms. It will not encourage people to drink ethanol anymore than most won't bungee-jump off the BRI tower.
As for local business people, they pay 1,000,000+ RP for dodgy spirits in the right bottle that they can pour for their entourages. These businessmen have no problem with paying premium prices for their entertainment. Who is affected by these 'laws'? The real toll is paid by those of us who want a beer after work, or a night out at a patio bar. We want a drink, but no desire to be criminals or to go blind drinking someone's hastily-bottled concoction.

So is it alcohol free now or can you still find beer if you look hard enough?

We can find beer at Hokky, Papaya and Ranch Supermarkets and there are a few industry contacts where we can buy cases. Of course you can still stop at hotels, bars, restaurants and outdoor venues like Spazio, and the Loop.

New topic

Questions and answers about Surabaya

Ask your question
Visitors to our spot of reality in Surabaya.
By duplez
Chris Liang
Looking for 2 week rental in Surabaya near Gubeng
By Chris Liang
By 1st.bass
Surabaya Expats, what to do an Saturday night
By MichaelMar
Assistance with a predicament in Jawa Timur
By indoz2

Expatriate health insurance in Surabaya

Free advice and quotation service to choose an expat health insurance in Surabaya

Moving to Surabaya

Find tips from professionals about moving to Surabaya

Travel insurance in Surabaya

Enjoy a stress-free travel across Surabaya

Flights to Surabaya

Find the best prices for your flight tickets to Surabaya